San Antonio Express-News MySA.com Copyright 2011, Paul Premack
September 2, 2011
What are the
legal formalities for changing a Will?
Dear Mr. Premack: If a codicil is not written in the personal
handwriting of the person who made the will, and is not signed, is it
legal to use it in the probate court? –P.H.
Your one-line question
requires a lot of background information in order to understand the
answer. The person who made the Will is legally called the “testator” (or,
in the somewhat dated legal jargon, “testatrix” if female). If the
testator made a valid Will at some earlier date and wants to change it,
specific legal formalities are necessary before the change can be
The Texas Probate Code lays out the requirements for a
valid Will, which are also the requirements for a valid modification to a
Will, which is referred to as a codicil. To be valid, the Will or codicil
must 1) be in writing, 2) be signed by the testator (or, in a rarely used
exception, signed by another person for the testator by his direction and
in his presence), and 3) be signed by two or more credible witnesses who
are above age fourteen. This type of witnessed will is referred to as an
“attested Will”. The only exception is that if the Will is holographic
(entirely in the testator’s handwriting) it need not be attested.
Other refinements necessary to make the Will function properly include 1)
self-proving the Will, and 2) being sure the Will is properly dated so
that it can be placed properly into its historical timeline.
Applying those standards to your question, the answer is “no”. You posit a
“codicil” that is not written in the personal handwriting of the testator.
It is not signed. Thus, it does not meet the legal formalities necessary
for it to be recognized as a Will or a codicil, and would not be admitted
to probate in court. In the same vein, handwritten notes jotted on an
attested Will are ignored because they are also unsigned.
modification to be acceptable, it must either 1) be wholly in the
testator’s handwriting and bearing the signature of the testator, or 2) be
in anyone’s hand or be typewritten, bearing the signature of the testator
placed before two qualified witnesses who also signed. These witnesses
cannot just attest in any way or at any time. They must, by law, see the
testator sign and must see each other sign and the testator must see them
Your question does raise an interesting legal issue: can an
attested Will be modified by a holographic codicil? The Texas Probate Code
states that any document that seeks to revoke part or all of a Will must
be “executed with like formalities” (inherently, a change to a prior Will
“revokes” part of it and replaces it with the new instructions). Does that
mean that an attested Will can only be changed using an attested codicil
(not by a holographic codicil)? Or that a holographic Will can only be
changed using a holographic codicil (not by an attested codicil)?
The statute gives no guidance, so as you might expect the ambiguity has
landed in court a number of times. One of the most recent decisions is
from the Texas Court of Appeals in Waco. In the Cason v. Taylor case, the
court ruled that, “While the statute says that the subsequent instrument
must be executed ‘with like formalities,’ this does not mean that a
typewritten, attested will can be revoked only by a later typewritten,
attested instrument, or that a holographic will can be revoked only by a
later holographic instrument… A holographic will can revoke an attested
will, and vice versa, so long as the revoking instrument is in accordance
with the legal requirements” for making a valid will.
“codicil” which you asked about would have worked had it been “in
accordance with the legal requirements”. If it had been in the testator’s
handwriting and signed by the testator, it would have been valid, even if
the Will it was changing had been a typewritten attested Will.
(...and note, the testator must have legal capacity to make a Will - which
is called "testamentary capacity".)
column answers a specific
legal question asked by an individual in Texas. The answer may or may not
match your individual situation. Be careful not to treat this column as
specific legal advice, as it may not meet your individual needs. It may
give you a solid basis for discussion with your own attorney.
You should consult with your personal
attorney before you take any action on this or any legal issue.
Also, please be aware that laws change, so this column is valid only
as of the date it was published. This communication does not create an
attorney-client relationship between the author and the reader.
NOTICE: The fact that you read this website does not make you our client nor
us your attorneys. The material and information on this website and associated
blogs are provided strictly for informational purposes and are not legal advice.
This site does not create an attorney-client relationship between our attorneys
and the users of this site. Visitors to this site should consult a licensed
attorney before taking any legal action.